Airports: Public Infrastructure Or Private Convenience?

Airports are a crucial part of a country's infrastructure, facilitating travel, tourism, and trade. They are complex systems involving both hardware and abstract systems, such as passenger terminals, runways, air traffic control towers, baggage systems, and organisational compositions. The funding for airport infrastructure comes from a mix of sources, including federal grants, user fees, and tenant rents and fees. As of 2020, nearly 20% of the world's airports were privately owned, with the remaining majority being publicly owned and managed.

Sources of airport infrastructure funding

Airports are powerful engines for economic opportunity, generating trillions in annual economic activity and supporting millions of jobs. However, as passenger traffic continues to grow, aviation infrastructure struggles to keep pace with the overwhelming demand. Airports face challenges in securing the necessary financing for improvements and modernisation, with a projected $115 billion in infrastructure needs over the next five years in the US alone.

Federal Grants

US airports received an average of over $14 billion annually for infrastructure projects between fiscal years 2013 and 2017, with the three largest funding sources being:

• Federal Airport Improvement Program (AIP) grants: AIP grants are backed by taxes, mostly on transportation, and are used for rehabilitating or constructing runways and taxiways, improving airfield safety, and enhancing security. Smaller airports tend to receive more AIP funding compared to larger airports.
• Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) local user fee: PFC is a per-passenger fee charged at the point of ticket purchase. It is used to fund FAA-approved airport improvement projects and has not been increased since 2000.
• Airport-generated revenue: This includes revenue from concessions, airline landing fees, and other sources. Larger airports tend to generate more revenue than smaller airports.

Bonds

Airports often use bonds, similar to a home mortgage, to finance capital projects such as constructing and renovating terminals, parking garages, and maintenance facilities. Tax-exempt municipal bonds, specifically Private Activity Bonds, are a cost-efficient form of infrastructure financing.

Tenant Rents and Fees

Airports charge airlines landing fees and terminal rents, which contribute to their funding.

State and Local Funding

State governments may provide funding for aviation as part of their transportation programs. Local funding is typically provided through tax revenue and usage fees collected by the airport sponsor or operator.

Other Sources

Some airports have obtained financing by issuing bonds secured by airport revenue or PFCs. Larger airports tend to have a greater and more certain revenue stream, making it easier for them to access capital markets and generate more bond proceeds.

Airport ownership

Private ownership is more common in Europe. Airports in Copenhagen, Zurich, and Rome Fiumicino are privately owned, with a minority government stake. Meanwhile, airports in Amsterdam, Paris, Frankfurt, Munich, and Madrid are majority government-owned but with private investment.

Many UK airports are privately owned, following privatisation by the government in 1987. Heathrow Airport, for example, is owned by a consortium known as FGP Topco Limited, which includes several companies such as the Spanish Infrastructure provider Ferrovial and the Qatar Investment Authority.

In Canada, most airports are now operated by individual legal authorities, such as the Vancouver International Airport Authority, although they are still owned by the federal government. Some airports, like Boundary Bay Airport and Pitt Meadows Airport, are municipally owned.

In some countries, particularly the US, airports typically have one or more fixed-base operators serving general aviation. Most of the world's large airports are owned by local, regional, or national government bodies, which then lease the airport to private corporations that oversee its operation. For example, the state-owned British Airports Authority originally operated eight of the UK's major commercial airports before it was privatised in the late 1980s. Frankfurt Airport in Germany is managed by the quasi-private firm Fraport, while Indira Gandhi International Airport and Rajiv Gandhi International Airport in India are operated by the GMR Group through joint ventures.

Despite the reluctance to privatise airports in the US, the government-owned, contractor-operated (GOCO) arrangement is the standard for the operation of commercial airports in the rest of the world.

Airport management

Ownership and Management

Airports can be owned by governments or private entities, with management structures varying depending on the ownership model. In the US, almost all major airports are government-owned, while private ownership is more common in Europe. Management of airports involves overseeing financial responsibilities, infrastructure development, and day-to-day operations.

Infrastructure Development and Maintenance

Airport infrastructure covers a wide range of systems, including passenger terminals, runways, air traffic control towers, baggage systems, lighting, and more. Maintaining and upgrading these systems is crucial for safety and efficiency, and it comes at a significant cost. From 2021 to 2030, an estimated $1.2 to $1.5 trillion is expected to be spent on airport infrastructure globally.

Financial Management

Funding for airport infrastructure projects comes from various sources, including federal grants, user fees, tenant rents and fees, and debt instruments such as bonds. Airports are typically expected to operate in a self-sustaining manner, generating revenue to fund their operations and improvements. Financial planning and securing the necessary funding are critical aspects of airport management.

Regulatory Compliance

Airports are subject to extensive regulation by government authorities, including aviation regulators and other bodies overseeing areas such as safety, security, and environmental protection. Ensuring compliance with these regulations is a key responsibility of airport management.

Terminal Infrastructure

Terminals are a critical component of the airport, providing a well-organized flow of passengers and efficient baggage handling systems. Terminal design, security, and capacity management are all important considerations for airport management.

Airfield Infrastructure

Airfield infrastructure includes runways, taxiways, apron areas, and associated signage and markings. Ensuring the proper maintenance and condition of these areas is essential for safe aircraft operations. Runway orientation, lighting, and markings follow standards set by organizations like the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).

Air Traffic Control

Air traffic control towers play a crucial role in managing aircraft movement. Airport management must ensure proper staffing, training, and technology for air traffic control operations.

Safety and Emergency Response

Strategic Planning

Stakeholder Coordination

Effective airport management requires coordination with various stakeholders, including airlines, government agencies, local communities, and passengers. Managing relationships and addressing their needs is essential for the airport's success.

Airport efficiency

Airport Infrastructure and Efficiency:

Airports require significant investments to maintain and upgrade their infrastructure. The upkeep of airport infrastructure is a costly endeavour, with an estimated $1.2 to $1.5 trillion expected to be spent globally between 2021 and 2030. Airports consist of various components, including terminals, runways, air traffic control towers, baggage systems, and more. Efficient airport infrastructure ensures smooth operations, safety, and a positive passenger experience. Delays in infrastructure upgrades can lead to increased costs and prolonged construction times, as seen in the case of US airports, which have faced funding challenges.

Airport Ownership and Management:

Airport ownership varies globally, with government and private ownership models. In the US, most major airports are government-owned, while European airports often have a mix of private ownership and government stakes. Airport management may be handled by the government or outsourced to private companies. Efficient airport management is crucial for optimising operations and ensuring a positive financial outlook.

Airport Funding and Finance:

Airport funding sources include user fees, government grants, tenant rents, and fees. In the US, airports are expected to be self-sustaining and receive limited direct taxpayer support. Federal programmes like the Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) and the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) provide funding for airport improvements. However, these funding sources may not be sufficient, and airports need to explore other options like bonds and private investments.

Challenges and Future of Airport Efficiency:

Airports face challenges, including ageing infrastructure, capacity constraints, and the need for technological upgrades. The COVID-19 pandemic also disrupted airport operations and reduced passenger traffic. To enhance efficiency, airports are embracing new technologies, such as remote air traffic control towers and automated systems. Additionally, the focus on sustainability and decarbonisation is driving the adoption of sustainable aviation fuel and the integration of new technologies like drones and electric aircraft.

Airport privatisation

In India, the Airports Authority of India (AAI) has been examining the possibility of selling loss-making airports alongside profitable ones, with the next round of bidding for the redevelopment of airports in public-private partnership expected to begin in the next financial year. This approach to privatisation, known as "clubbing", aims to package a profitable airport with a loss-making one to make the sale more attractive to potential bidders.

The United Kingdom provides an interesting case study in airport privatisation. In 1987, the British Airports Authority (BAA) privatised Heathrow Airport and six other UK airports. Since then, BAA has sold off several airports to increase competition and now operates only London Heathrow under the name Heathrow Airport Holdings. Heathrow Airport Holdings is owned by a consortium of several companies, including the Spanish infrastructure provider Ferrovial, the Qatar Investment Authority, and the Government of Singapore.

While airport privatisation can bring benefits such as improved service and increased income, there are also potential drawbacks. Critics of privatisation argue that increased public investment can deliver similar improvements, and that most airports are already financially self-sufficient. Additionally, complications around tax-free status and airline opposition have impeded airport privatisation efforts in some countries, such as the United States.

In conclusion, airport privatisation is a complex issue that varies depending on the country and the specific circumstances of the airports involved. While privatisation can have benefits, it is important to carefully consider the potential drawbacks and challenges before proceeding.

Frequently asked questions