Sullenberger's Options: Could He Have Made It?

On January 15, 2009, Captain Chesley Sully Sullenberger III, a former fighter pilot, was in command of US Airways Flight 1549, an Airbus A320, which took off from New York City's LaGuardia Airport. Shortly after takeoff, the plane struck a flock of Canada geese, resulting in both engines being disabled. With quick thinking and expertise, Sullenberger, along with First Officer Jeffrey Skiles, executed a successful emergency landing on the Hudson River. All 155 people on board were rescued, and the incident became known as the Miracle on the Hudson. While some questioned Sullenberger's decision to land in the Hudson, investigations concluded that it was the correct choice under the circumstances. This event highlighted the importance of aviation safety and led to discussions about preparing for similar rare occurrences in the future.

The time taken to assess the situation

The time needed to assess the situation was a critical factor in the US Airways Flight 1549 incident. After taking off from LaGuardia Airport in New York City on January 15, 2009, the plane, piloted by Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, collided with a flock of Canada geese. This resulted in severe damage to both engines and an almost complete loss of thrust.

In the immediate aftermath of the bird strike, Sullenberger and his co-pilot, First Officer Jeffrey Skiles, faced a critical situation that required swift decision-making. Sullenberger took control of the plane while Skiles worked through the checklist for engine restart. Recognizing the urgency, Sullenberger radioed a mayday call, informing air traffic control that they had hit birds and lost thrust on both engines. He requested landing options in New Jersey, including Teterboro Airport.

However, the time required to assess the situation and make a decision was limited. Sullenberger had to consider the low altitude of the plane, the proximity to available airports, and the deteriorating performance of the aircraft. He quickly determined that they would be unable to reach LaGuardia Airport or Teterboro Airport. This assessment, based on his experience and expertise, led to the crucial decision to glide the plane towards the Hudson River for an emergency water landing.

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) later affirmed that the ditching in the Hudson River provided the highest probability of survival under the circumstances. While flight simulations showed that the plane could have returned to LaGuardia, these scenarios did not account for the time necessary for the pilots to understand and assess the situation. Sullenberger's swift assessment and subsequent decision to glide towards the Hudson River played a pivotal role in ensuring the safety of all 155 passengers and crew members on board.

Risk of crashing in a densely populated area

The risk of crashing in a densely populated area was a key consideration for Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger when deciding where to land US Airways Flight 1549 after a bird strike on January 15, 2009.

Shortly after taking off from LaGuardia Airport in New York City, the Airbus A320, serving 150 passengers and 5 crew members, collided with a flock of Canada geese. This resulted in severe engine damage and an almost complete loss of thrust. Despite repeated attempts, the pilots were unable to restart the engines.

Faced with the possibility of engine failure, Sullenberger considered returning to LaGuardia Airport or diverting to an airport in New Jersey. However, he quickly determined that the plane would be unable to reach either of these destinations due to its low altitude and proximity to the airports. Sullenberger was aware that attempting to reach an unreachable runway could lead to a catastrophic crash in a densely populated area, endangering both those on board and people on the ground.

As a result, Sullenberger made the split-second decision to glide the plane into the Hudson River for an emergency water landing. This choice was later affirmed by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) as providing the highest probability of survival under the circumstances. All 155 people on board were rescued by nearby boats, and there were no fatalities.

While some criticized Sullenberger's decision to land in the Hudson River, a detailed investigation by the NTSB concluded that it was the appropriate course of action. The investigation considered various factors, including the time required for the pilots to assess the situation and the potential risk of crashing in a densely populated area. Simulations performed at the Airbus Training Center in Toulouse, France, showed that the plane could have barely made it back to LaGuardia, but these scenarios did not account for real-world considerations and the possibility of a catastrophic crash.

In his book, "Highest Duty: My Search for What Really Matters," Sullenberger reflected on his decision, stating that he knew he had to be certain they could make it back to LaGuardia. He understood that turning toward LaGuardia would be an irrevocable choice, ruling out all other options. Sullenberger also emphasized the potential consequences of attempting to reach an unreachable runway, which could have had disastrous results for those on board and on the ground.

Sully's experience and expertise

Chesley Burnett "Sully" Sullenberger III is a retired US Airways captain with over 50 years and 20,000 hours of flying experience. He has a Bachelor of Science degree in psychology and basic sciences from the United States Air Force Academy, a master's degree in industrial-organizational psychology from Purdue University, and a Master of Public Administration from the University of Northern Colorado.

Sullenberger's extensive experience includes serving as an instructor pilot, flight leader, and training officer in the United States Air Force, where he attained the rank of captain. He has been involved in several accident investigations with the USAF and the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), and has served as an instructor, air safety chairman, accident investigator, and national technical committee member with the Air Line Pilots Association.

Sullenberger's expertise in aviation safety is well-recognised, and he has been an outspoken advocate for aviation safety, helping to develop new protocols and improve safety measures. He has co-authored a paper on error-inducing contexts in aviation with NASA scientists and studied the psychology behind keeping an airline crew functioning during a crisis.

On January 15, 2009, Sullenberger's quick decision-making, expertise, and calm composure were put to the test when his US Airways Flight 1549 collided with a flock of birds shortly after takeoff from LaGuardia Airport in New York City. With both engines disabled, he assessed the situation and determined that returning to LaGuardia or diverting to a nearby airport was not feasible. Instead, he skillfully executed a water landing on the Hudson River, ensuring the safety of all 155 passengers and crew on board.

Sullenberger's handling of the emergency and his extensive experience and expertise were widely praised. He was recognised for his heroic actions and received numerous awards, including the National Air and Space Museum Trophy for Current Achievement and the Legion of Honour from France.

The plane's glide descent

On January 15, 2009, Chesley Burnett "Sully" Sullenberger III, an American retired aviator, diplomat, and aviation safety expert, was the captain of US Airways Flight 1549, an Airbus A320, taking off from LaGuardia Airport in New York City. Shortly after takeoff, the plane struck a flock of Canada geese, causing both engines to lose power.

Sullenberger and his co-pilot, First Officer Jeffrey Skiles, decided to glide the plane and ditch it on the Hudson River near Midtown Manhattan. All 155 people on board were rescued by nearby boats, and there were no fatalities. This incident became known as the "Miracle on the Hudson".

The glide descent began after the bird strike, when the aircraft slowed but continued to climb for about 19 seconds, reaching about 3,060 feet at an airspeed of about 185 knots. The plane then began its glide descent, accelerating to 210 knots as it descended through 1,650 feet. Sullenberger radioed a mayday call and attempted to turn back towards LaGuardia Airport, but he quickly determined that the plane would be unable to reach it.

The glide descent and subsequent water landing were a result of the loss of power in both engines and the low altitude of the aircraft, which prevented it from reaching any nearby airports. Sullenberger's quick decision-making, precision flying, and teamwork with Skiles ensured the successful ditching of the plane and the safe evacuation of all passengers and crew.

The proximity of working vessels to the ditching site

The Airbus A320, piloted by Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, was forced to make an unpowered ditching into the Hudson River after a bird strike caused the loss of all engine power shortly after takeoff from LaGuardia Airport in New York City. The proximity of working vessels, including ferries and boats from the U.S. Coast Guard, played a crucial role in the rescue operation.

Within minutes of the ditching, two NY Waterway ferries arrived on the scene and began taking people aboard using a Jason's cradle. Numerous other boats, including those from the U.S. Coast Guard, were also quickly on hand to assist with the rescue. Sullenberger advised the ferry crews to prioritize rescuing those on the wings, as they were in a more precarious situation than those on the slides, which had detached to become life rafts. The last person was taken off the plane at 15:55, approximately 25 minutes after the ditching.

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) identified the proximity of working vessels to the ditching site as one of the key factors contributing to the successful outcome of the incident. The NTSB's final report recognized the rapid response times of the ferry operators and emergency responders, who played a vital role in ensuring the safety of those on board.

Frequently asked questions