Biometric Screening At Airports: Effective Security Measure?

Biometric screening at airports is becoming increasingly common, with many airlines and airports adopting the technology. The use of biometrics is designed to enhance security and improve the passenger experience by simplifying and speeding up the departure process. However, while some travellers welcome the increased efficiency and convenience, others have expressed concerns about privacy and the potential for misuse of personal data. So, does biometric screening work, and what are the implications for travellers and the aviation industry?

Privacy concerns

Biometric screening at airports is designed to verify passengers' identities by cross-checking facial scans with passport photos already on file. While this technology promises greater convenience for airline passengers, it also raises privacy concerns.

The use of biometric technology at airports has sparked concerns about privacy and civil liberties. Critics argue that it constitutes an invasion of privacy and a step towards creating a comprehensive tracking system. Jay Stanley, a policy analyst with the American Civil Liberties Union, expressed fears that society could move towards one where individuals are constantly tracked. In a 2018 poll, 44% of 2000 adult internet users viewed such systems unfavourably, while only 27% viewed them favourably.

However, it is important to note that participation in biometric technology tests is voluntary. Passengers can choose to opt out of facial scans, instead relying on regular passports and boarding passes. Additionally, the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is committed to protecting passenger privacy and securing personal data collected during biometric tests. They adhere to strict cybersecurity measures and transform passenger photos into templates that cannot be reverse-engineered to recreate the original image.

Despite these assurances, privacy advocates worry about the potential for misuse or abuse of personal data. They argue that the convenience of faster boarding times should not come at the cost of sacrificing privacy. Furthermore, there are concerns about the accuracy of biometric technologies and the potential for false positives or negatives, which could lead to further security issues.

To address these concerns, TSA conducts rigorous scientific studies and collaborates with various partners to identify and mitigate performance issues. They also publish Privacy Impact Assessments to notify the public about tests and provide additional information on privacy protections.

In conclusion, while biometric screening at airports offers enhanced security and convenience, it also raises valid privacy concerns that need to be carefully addressed by relevant authorities to ensure the protection of passengers' personal information and prevent potential misuse.

Efficiency and speed

Biometric screening at airports has been adopted as a means to enhance security and operational efficiency, and to improve the passenger experience. The technology has been hailed as a way to automate current manual ID verification procedures, thus speeding up the process and confirming passenger identity more accurately.

The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) in the US, for example, is testing one-to-one facial matching capabilities by integrating a camera that will take a picture of a passenger and compare it to the image on their photo ID. This is done using Credential Authentication Technology 2 (CAT-2). This approach does not require a database of pre-staged images, as it simply compares the image from the document presented by the passenger against an image taken of them at the checkpoint.

The use of biometrics in airports can provide a contactless way of identity verification. It can confirm a traveller's identity and their entry or exit, with an increased ability to detect fraudulent documents and visa overstays. For instance, the US Department of Homeland Security's Biometric Entry Exit Program uses the Traveller Verification System (TVS) to biometrically confirm a traveller's identity and their entry or exit.

The adoption of biometric technology at airports has been accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, as it provides a more hygienic, contactless passenger experience. Biometric scanners at airports have become a way to facilitate contactless boarding, reducing touchpoints in the airline and airport experience.

The benefits of biometric screening include increased efficiency and speed of the boarding process. Initial trials by Delta found that passengers saved an average of nine minutes at the gate per flight when using biometric boarding. British Airways also reported that its system made it possible to board 400 passengers in just 22 minutes, less than half the usual time. Vision-Box, a company that provides biometric technology at over 100 airports, has noted that its biometric boarding system can board 400 people in 20 minutes, which was confirmed in a similar test at Los Angeles International Airport.

However, it is important to note that the implementation of biometric technology at airports faces several challenges, including privacy concerns, security issues, and infrastructure problems.

Accuracy and equity

The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is committed to addressing concerns related to the accuracy of biometric technologies, including facial recognition. TSA's exploration of biometric solutions is grounded in rigorous scientific study and analysis, with the agency carefully studying and testing these technologies in collaboration with federal partners, industry players, and academic institutions.

TSA recognizes the importance of accuracy and equity in biometric system performance and is proactively identifying and mitigating performance issues. They are evaluating the impact of digital identity documents and upgrading systems with enhanced capabilities. The agency is also working to protect passenger privacy and secure all personal data collected during biometric testing.

To ensure accuracy, TSA is testing 1:1 facial matching by integrating a camera that compares a passenger's photo to their photo ID. They are also testing 1:n facial identification by using the Traveler Verification Service to match a live image of a passenger to a database of pre-enrolled reference photos.

The U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has proposed key changes to enhance the accuracy and equity of biometric authentication. These include a more stringent accuracy requirement for authentication, a revamped risk management approach, and an amended process for assurance level selection. NIST is also planning consultations to provide guidance on equity within the Base Volume and may introduce risk scoring metrics.

While biometric screening at airports raises privacy concerns, TSA's efforts demonstrate a commitment to accuracy and equity, with ongoing testing and evaluations to address performance issues and protect passenger data.

Data protection

Biometric screening at airports has raised concerns about data protection and user privacy. While biometric technology can provide a contactless way of identity verification, it also poses challenges regarding data security and user consent.

In the United States, the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is committed to protecting passenger privacy and securing all personal data collected during biometric testing. They adhere to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) policies and cybersecurity requirements to safeguard personally identifiable information (PII). For example, TSA transforms passenger photos into templates that cannot be reverse-engineered, and they only retain PII for as long as necessary, following the DHS Fair Information Practice Principles (FIPPs).

However, there have been instances that highlight the vulnerabilities of biometric data. In 2019, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) disclosed that its facial recognition database had been hacked, resulting in the theft of facial images and license plate data of an estimated 100,000 people. Additionally, a 2020 study by the U.S. Government Accountability Office found that CBP had been inconsistent in providing information about user consent for facial recognition scans, with privacy notices not always being visible.

To address these concerns, airports and government agencies are implementing measures to improve data protection. For instance, CBP states that photos used for biometric boarding are stored temporarily in the cloud and deleted within 12 hours of verification. Additionally, electronic forms and consumer education have been proposed to enhance transparency about the data stored and shared during biometric checks.

As biometric technology evolves and becomes more prevalent in airports, addressing data protection and privacy concerns will be crucial to maintaining user trust and confidence in the system.

Biometric IDs for domestic flights

The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) is currently evaluating the use of biometric technologies to enhance security, improve operational efficiency, and streamline the passenger experience while protecting privacy and civil liberties. TSA's exploration of biometric technologies is scientifically driven and capitalizes on significant advances in biometric accuracy, speed, and automation.

In recent years, TSA has been testing biometrics to identify passengers at checkpoints and is continuing to evaluate the use of proven and emerging solutions to understand their operational impact, security gains, and policy implications. These tests are voluntary, and passengers can opt for a standard ID check.

TSA's Biometrics Roadmap outlines plans to transform aviation security operations using biometric technology through four key goals:

• Partnering on biometrics for international travelers
• Operationalizing biometrics for TSA PreCheck®
• Expanding biometrics to additional domestic travelers
• Associated objectives and guiding principles, including security, operational effectiveness, privacy, and cybersecurity

The expansion of facial recognition for domestic travel could start with passengers who have passports or who have enrolled in the TSA PreCheck program, which requires a photo as part of the application process. TSA is also testing 1:1 facial matching capabilities by integrating a camera that will take a passenger's picture and compare it to the image on their photo ID, such as a passport or driver's license, using Credential Authentication Technology 2 (CAT-2).

As of 2024, there are 238 airports using Biometric Facial Comparison Technology in the air entry environment, including 14 CBP Preclearance locations and 49 locations for international departures. The use of biometrics for domestic flights is part of TSA's plan to enhance security and improve the passenger experience.

Frequently asked questions