Airport Shutdown: Is Government Intervention Possible?

A government shutdown could have a significant impact on air travel, with the potential for longer wait times at airports and disruptions to the aviation industry. While commercial airplanes will still fly, and essential workers like air traffic controllers and TSA agents will continue working, they will do so without pay, which may lead to increased sick days and staff shortages. This could result in longer lines at security checkpoints and potential temporary terminal closures, causing frustration for travelers and the aviation industry. The financial implications for the travel sector are also significant, with an estimated potential loss of $1 billion per week.

Air traffic controllers and TSA agents are considered essential and will continue working without pay

Air travel is a crucial aspect of modern life, facilitating connections between people, businesses, and cultures worldwide. Even during a government shutdown, air traffic controllers and TSA agents are deemed essential personnel, ensuring that airports remain operational. While these dedicated professionals continue their work, they do so without receiving paychecks, a situation that can create significant financial challenges. This scenario unfolded during the 2018-2019 government shutdown, which lasted over a month, from December 2018 through January 2019.

Air traffic controllers and TSA agents are vital to maintaining the safety and efficiency of air travel. Despite their essential roles, they are often required to work without pay during government shutdowns. This situation arises from the nature of government shutdowns, where the absence of approved funding leads to federal agencies halting operations and furloughing workers. However, certain essential services, including air traffic control and TSA security, must continue to operate even without funding.

During the 2018-2019 shutdown, air traffic controllers and TSA agents persevered in their duties despite the financial strain. This dedication, however, does not come without consequences. The lack of pay can lead to increased absenteeism, as witnessed during the 2019 shutdown when a significant number of air traffic controllers and TSA officers called in sick or found alternative sources of income. This resulted in flight disruptions and longer wait times at airports, causing inconvenience and frustration for travellers.

The impact of working without pay extends beyond the immediate financial strain. It can also affect the morale and motivation of these essential workers, potentially leading to higher rates of absenteeism and turnover. Moreover, the uncertainty surrounding government shutdowns can create a sense of instability for these employees, impacting their overall well-being.

To address this situation, retroactive paychecks are provided to these workers once the shutdown ends. However, this does not negate the challenges faced during the period without pay. The financial strain and uncertainty can lead to difficulties in managing personal finances, including mortgage payments, rent, and other essential expenses.

In conclusion, while air traffic controllers and TSA agents are considered essential during government shutdowns, the reality of working without pay underscores the dedication and resilience of these professionals. Their continued service ensures the safety and efficiency of air travel, even during periods of political impasse.

Longer wait times at airports due to reduced staffing

While a government shutdown would not ground commercial airplanes, it could result in longer wait times at airports due to reduced staffing. Air traffic controllers and Transportation Security Administration (TSA) agents are deemed essential workers and would continue working without pay during a shutdown. However, this could lead to longer lines and wait times at security checkpoints, especially during busy travel seasons.

During previous government shutdowns, such as the one that occurred during the first Trump administration from late December 2018 to early 2019, travelers experienced longer wait times at airports. This was due to a combination of factors, including reduced staffing as a result of essential workers calling out or quitting after missing paychecks. In some cases, travelers had to wait in security lines for up to an hour and a half, causing some to miss their flights.

To mitigate the potential impact on wait times, airports have implemented various measures. For example, Orlando International Airport, Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International Airport, and San Antonio International Airport installed systems that provide estimated wait times using Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and video analytics. Additionally, some airports have invested in new technology, such as CT security scanners, which have helped reduce queue times by allowing travelers to keep liquids and laptops in their hand luggage.

Furthermore, the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) has stated that its personnel are prepared to handle high volumes of travelers and ensure safe travel. However, they have also acknowledged that an extended shutdown could result in longer wait times at airports. This is a significant concern, especially during the busy holiday travel season when airports are expecting to screen millions of passengers.

To summarize, while commercial flights will continue to operate during a government shutdown, travelers may experience longer wait times at airports due to reduced staffing and higher passenger volumes. Airports have implemented technological solutions to mitigate this issue, but an extended shutdown could still result in significant delays for passengers.

Furloughed federal employees and essential workers will be paid retroactively

During a government shutdown, most federal agencies stop operating, and most government workers are furloughed. However, those who work in agencies deemed to provide "essential services", such as the U.S. Transportation Security Administration (TSA), are not furloughed. In the case of the TSA, 59,000 out of 62,000 employees are considered essential and would continue working without pay during a shutdown. This means that airport security workers and air traffic controllers would still be required to work, but they would not receive paychecks until the shutdown ends.

While air travel would not be significantly impacted at first, there could be longer TSA wait times and an overall slowdown in passport processing times. Absenteeism could also present a challenge for these agencies, and the FAA continues to struggle with labour shortages since the pandemic, leading to flight cuts at major airports. During a 2019 shutdown, an increased number of air traffic controllers called in sick or fatigued, leading to a temporary shutdown at LaGuardia Airport and delays at other major airports.

Furloughed federal employees and essential workers who work through a shutdown will be paid retroactively once the government reopens. However, employees of government contractors do not have the same guarantee and will not receive back pay.

The impact on the US travel economy and the potential loss of $1 billion per week

The US travel economy is a significant contributor to the nation's overall economic success, generating $1.3 trillion in 2024. However, a government shutdown could cost the US travel economy up to $1 billion per week, according to the US Travel Association. This loss is attributed to the impact on millions of American travellers, businesses, and federal workers.

During a government shutdown, most federal agencies cease operations, and federal workers are furloughed, except for those providing "'essential services', such as air traffic control and transportation security. Despite being deemed essential, these workers would not receive paychecks until the shutdown ends, potentially leading to absenteeism and longer wait times at airports.

The impact of a shutdown is exacerbated by the timing, coinciding with the holiday travel season, one of the busiest on record. With TSA administrators expecting to screen over 40 million passengers during this period, any disruptions or delays could significantly affect the travel industry.

The last government shutdown, from late 2018 to early 2019, resulted in a loss of $11 billion to the nation's economy, according to the Congressional Budget Office. This included substantial losses for towns and cities that rely on national parks and monuments as major tourism attractions. The shutdown also negatively impacted small businesses located near these parks, with losses estimated at $20 million per day.

A government shutdown could once again result in similar economic losses, inconveniencing travellers, disrupting businesses, and causing financial hardship for federal workers and contractors. The potential loss of $1 billion per week in the travel economy underlines the urgency of congressional action to prevent a shutdown and mitigate the adverse effects on the travel industry and the broader economy.

The effect on federal workers, with some quitting during previous shutdowns

During a government shutdown, most federal agencies stop working, and most government workers are furloughed. However, those who work in agencies deemed to provide "essential services", such as U.S. Transportation Security Administration (TSA) workers, are required to continue working without pay. While these workers will receive back pay once the shutdown ends, the lack of immediate compensation can cause financial strain and lead to absenteeism.

During the 2018-2019 government shutdown, which lasted 35 days, many federal workers were forced to go without pay over the holiday season. This resulted in high levels of absenteeism, as workers sought other ways to make money. According to Sen. Mark Warner, some federal employees may also be pulled away from their day-to-day jobs to prepare for a funding lapse, causing further disruptions to essential services.

In the case of air travel, the impact of a government shutdown can be significant. While TSA workers and air traffic controllers are deemed essential and required to work, a shortage of staff can lead to longer wait times at airports and potential flight delays or even temporary shutdowns at certain airports. During the 2018-2019 shutdown, a rise in absenteeism among air traffic controllers resulted in a temporary shutdown at LaGuardia Airport and delays at several other major airports.

The impact of a government shutdown on federal workers varies depending on their specific agency and position. However, the prospect of going without pay can be a significant source of stress and financial hardship, leading some workers to quit their jobs. The disruption to essential services and the economy caused by a government shutdown underscores the importance of finding a resolution to avoid prolonged lapses in funding.

Frequently asked questions