Airports Vs Grocery Stores: Where's The Real Danger?

A study by the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health has found that flying during the pandemic is safer than other common activities such as going to the grocery store or eating inside a restaurant. The study highlights that the frequent exchange of air and HEPA filters on planes remove over 99% of particles containing COVID-19 from the cabin air, significantly reducing the risk of virus transmission. However, the study also emphasizes the importance of mask-wearing, social distancing, and hand hygiene practices to further mitigate the risk of infection. While this study provides valuable insights, it is important to consider the potential impact of other factors, such as airport operations and ground transportation, on the overall safety of air travel during the pandemic.

Ventilation systems on planes

Ventilation systems are a crucial component of any modern aircraft capable of flying at high altitudes. They play a vital role in maintaining a comfortable and healthy environment for passengers and crew. Here are some key details about ventilation systems on planes:

Types of Ventilation Systems:

• Mixing Ventilation (MV): This is the traditional system used in aircraft, which creates a uniform air temperature distribution by mixing air in the cabin. While it ensures thermal comfort, it also enhances the spread of airborne contaminants.
• Displacement Ventilation (DV): This system supplies clean air through diffusers near the floor and exhausts it through ceiling diffusers, creating a more comfortable and healthier environment. It has been found to reduce drafts and improve thermal comfort, especially for aisle seats, by creating a more homogeneous cabin airflow.
• Ceiling-based Cabin Displacement Ventilation (CCDV): This system combines overhead and floor-based displacement ventilation. It aims to improve thermal comfort and energy efficiency by reducing energy consumption.
• Under-aisle Displacement Ventilation: This system supplies conditioned air through a narrow channel along the side cabin walls and provides additional humid air through perforated under-aisle panels. It aims to reduce the risk of infectious disease transmission and improve relative humidity.

Benefits and Effectiveness:

The ventilation systems in aircraft cabins are highly effective in maintaining air quality and reducing the risk of infection. Here are some key benefits:

• Air Exchange and Filtration: Cabin air is exchanged and filtered frequently, with modern HEPA filters removing over 99% of particles, including viruses. This significantly reduces the risk of virus transmission.
• Reduced Infection Risk: The ventilation systems, combined with other measures like mask-wearing and surface disinfection, make flying safer than other activities like grocery shopping during the pandemic.
• Improved Thermal Comfort: Certain ventilation systems, like DV and CCDV, provide improved thermal comfort for passengers, especially those in aisle seats, by creating a more homogeneous cabin airflow and reducing drafts.
• Allergen Control: Ventilation systems help control allergens by circulating air across the aircraft rather than along the passenger cabin. This reduces the spread of allergens generated by fellow passengers.

Recommendations and Future Improvements:

Researchers and experts have made several recommendations and suggested future improvements for aircraft ventilation systems:

• Ground Ventilation: Researchers recommend that airlines acquire additional ventilation systems on the ground to ensure proper ventilation during embarkation and disembarkation procedures.
• Strict Mask Adherence: To further reduce the risk of infection, researchers emphasize the importance of strict mask adherence by passengers and recommend airlines enforce this through policies and, if necessary, placement on no-fly lists.
• Hybrid Systems: Combining different ventilation systems, such as floor and ceiling-based displacement ventilation, can provide high heat removal efficiency, comfortable flow conditions, and improved temperature distribution.
• Personalized Ventilation: This system provides the best air quality without draft risks and is recommended for improving air quality and thermal comfort.

Masks and disinfection

The study also recommends disinfection of high-touch surfaces, such as armrests, tray tables, belt buckles, window blinds, and toilet locks, both during and between flights. Proper disinfection of these surfaces is crucial, as viruses like COVID-19 can survive for extended periods on hard surfaces.

Additionally, the study suggests that passengers should be encouraged to monitor their health and provide certificates confirming they are symptom-free and committed to adhering to mask policies. These measures, combined with proper ventilation and filtration systems, contribute to making air travel safer than other activities such as grocery shopping during the pandemic.

It is worth noting that the study focuses solely on the aircraft and does not include airport operations, which may pose additional risks.

Social distancing

Maintaining social distancing in airports and on flights can be challenging. However, airlines can make deliberate choices about flight loads and how passengers are distributed throughout the cabin. Passengers should also maintain social distancing during boarding and disembarking, in addition to wearing masks and practising good hand hygiene.

The Harvard paper recommends that airlines implement "layered risk mitigation strategies" and that passengers abide by the rules and monitor their own health. The paper's authors suggest that passengers who do not follow the rules could be placed on a no-fly list.

Overall, while social distancing can be difficult in airports and on flights, it is an important part of the layered approach to reducing the risk of COVID-19 transmission recommended by Harvard's T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

Health screening

Passengers should be encouraged to self-screen for COVID-19 symptoms and provide personal health certificates. They should also be honest about any symptoms and commit to wearing masks throughout the journey, except when eating or drinking. This self-screening, along with mask-wearing, is a critical part of keeping travellers safe and healthy.

Additionally, health screening procedures should include temperature checks at the airport and health declaration forms, where passengers disclose any recent exposure to COVID-19 or any symptoms they may be experiencing. These measures can help identify potentially infected individuals before they board the aircraft.

The combination of health screening, ventilation, disinfection, and mask-wearing creates a safe travel environment, reducing the risk of COVID-19 transmission during air travel.

Airport operations

While the Harvard study focuses on the safety of air travel, it is important to consider the broader context of airport operations and how they fit into the overall risk assessment. Airports are complex environments with multiple touchpoints and high foot traffic, which can potentially increase the risk of COVID-19 transmission.

The study acknowledges that maintaining social distancing in airports can be challenging, especially at departure gates and concourses. However, the researchers recommend implementing layered risk mitigation strategies, including strict mask-wearing policies, enhanced sanitation procedures, and health screening protocols. These measures aim to minimise the risk of transmission within the airport environment.

Additionally, the study suggests that proper ventilation and air filtration systems in airports can also play a crucial role in reducing the risk of virus transmission. Ground recommendations include acquiring additional ventilation systems during embarkation and disembarkation procedures to ensure proper airflow and minimise potential exposure.

The findings of the Harvard study have significant implications for airport operations. By following the recommended protocols, such as mask-wearing, social distancing, and enhanced sanitation, airports can contribute to lowering the risk of COVID-19 transmission. However, it is essential to recognise that the overall safety of air travel is a combination of both in-flight and airport measures.

Furthermore, the study highlights the importance of passenger compliance with health and safety guidelines. Educating travellers about their role in maintaining a safe airport environment can further reduce the risk of virus transmission. Transparent communication of safety protocols and enforcement of compliance are crucial aspects of airport operations in mitigating the spread of COVID-19.

Frequently asked questions