Airports Post-9/11: Are They Now Safe Havens?

On September 11, 2001, 19 terrorists boarded and hijacked four commercial flights, crashing them into the World Trade Center, the Pentagon, and a field in Shanksville, Pennsylvania. This deadly attack, which claimed the lives of nearly 3,000 people, exposed critical security gaps in airports, leading to significant changes in the aviation industry. In the aftermath, measures were swiftly implemented to prevent similar attacks, including stricter screening procedures, reinforced cockpit doors, and the creation of the Transportation Security Administration (TSA). While these enhancements have improved safety, the evolving nature of threats and the expansion of target areas, such as check-in lobbies and arrivals, underscore the ongoing challenge of securing airports and airplanes.

The creation of the Transportation Security Administration (TSA)

The TSA was created to improve airport security procedures and consolidate air travel security under a combined federal law enforcement and regulatory agency. It was designed to prevent similar attacks in the future and strengthen transportation security systems while ensuring the freedom of movement for people and commerce.

Initially, a part of the Department of Transportation, the TSA became a part of the Department of Homeland Security in March 2003. The TSA's primary mission is airport security and the prevention of aircraft hijacking. It is responsible for screening passengers and baggage at more than 450 US airports, employing screening officers, explosives detection dog handlers, and bomb technicians. The TSA also oversees security for other modes of transportation, such as passenger rail, bus networks, and highways.

The creation of the TSA marked a significant shift in airport security, with the implementation of new procedures and technologies. This included the installation of machines to screen baggage for explosives, programs to arm pilots, and enhanced cockpit security. The TSA also introduced more intrusive security measures, such as pat-downs and full-body scanners, which have been controversial due to privacy and health concerns.

The establishment of the TSA has had a noticeable impact on the airport experience for travellers, with longer checkpoint lines and more time spent at the airport. The TSA has also faced criticism and controversy over the effectiveness of its procedures, baggage theft, data security, and allegations of racial profiling and mistreatment of passengers. Despite this, the TSA continues to evolve its security measures to address ever-changing threats and enhance aviation security.

The implementation of full-body scanners

Full-body scanners were first implemented at airports in the 2000s, but they became a standard security measure after a Nigerian man on a flight from Amsterdam to Detroit attempted to detonate an explosive device he had hidden in his underwear. This incident, which took place in 2009, highlighted the need for more advanced screening technology to detect non-metallic objects.

There are two main types of full-body scanners: millimeter-wave scanners and backscatter X-ray scanners. Millimeter-wave scanners use non-ionizing electromagnetic radiation to produce a 3D image of a person, while backscatter X-ray scanners use low doses of ionizing radiation to detect metallic and non-metallic items.

The use of backscatter X-ray scanners sparked concerns about privacy and health risks. These scanners could produce detailed images of a person's body, including genitalia and other private features. There were also worries that the machines were saving images of travelers, raising serious privacy concerns. In addition, the use of ionizing radiation led to questions about potential health implications, including the risk of cancer. As a result, backscatter X-ray scanners were phased out of most airports by 2013.

To address privacy concerns, millimeter-wave scanners have been equipped with privacy software called Automated Target Recognition, which blurs private body parts and only displays a chalk outline of the individual. These scanners also have features to prevent the storage and export of images, addressing concerns about the improper saving and dissemination of images.

The introduction of the TSA PreCheck program

Background and Rationale

The TSA PreCheck program was introduced in December 2011 by the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) as a way to enhance security and improve the travel experience. By enrolling in the program, travellers could undergo a more detailed background check and enjoy a smoother and faster screening process at the airport. This program was especially appealing to frequent travellers who wanted to save time and have a more predictable experience at security checkpoints.

Application and Enrolment Process

To apply for TSA PreCheck, individuals must visit an enrolment centre in person and provide documentation, fingerprints, and a non-refundable fee to cover background check costs. The application process includes submitting identity/citizenship documentation, with exact name matches required across all documents. U.S. citizens, U.S. nationals, and lawful permanent residents are eligible to apply, along with citizens of partner countries enrolled in specific trusted traveller programs.

Benefits and Features

Once approved for the TSA PreCheck program, travellers can expect a more efficient and convenient security screening process. Participants no longer need to remove their shoes, belts, light jackets, or laptops, and they can keep their 3-1-1 liquids in their carry-on bags. Children under 17 can also accompany an adult with TSA PreCheck when indicated on their boarding pass. With over 200 participating airports and 90 airlines, the program offers a smoother journey for eligible travellers.

Wait Times and Privacy Concerns

The TSA PreCheck program significantly reduces wait times at security checkpoints, with 99% of participants waiting less than 10 minutes. However, privacy concerns have been raised regarding the amount of personal information collected during the application process, including work history, residence history, and fingerprinting. Additionally, there are concerns about the use of social media postings, press reports, location data, and information from data brokers.

Impact and Future Plans

The TSA PreCheck program has been successful in providing expedited screening for trusted travellers, allowing the TSA to focus resources on higher-risk individuals. Over 10 million people have enrolled in the program, and the TSA aims to expand this number to 25 million. The use of private vendors to gather applicant information and the potential exposure of personal information to hackers have sparked further discussions about privacy and security.

The impact on airport wait times

The terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, had a profound impact on airport security and wait times. In the aftermath, airports implemented stricter security measures, leading to longer lines and wait times for passengers.

Prior to 9/11, airport security was relatively relaxed. There were no lengthy checkpoint lines, and passengers could arrive at the airport just minutes before their flight, keeping their shoes and coats on as they walked through a simple metal detector. Friends and family could accompany travellers to the gate, postponing farewells until the last moment.

However, the deadly attacks exposed the vulnerabilities of airport security, as the terrorists exploited these lax measures to carry out their plan. In response, airports tightened security significantly. The creation of the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) in the U.S. federalised airport security and introduced stricter screening procedures. Similar measures were adopted worldwide.

The new security protocols included enhanced screening of carry-on bags and pat-downs of passengers, leading to longer wait times even with fewer travellers. The list of prohibited items expanded, banning sharp objects like knives and box cutters used by the 9/11 hijackers. The requirement to remove shoes during screenings was introduced after the "shoe bomber" incident in December 2001, and restrictions on liquids emerged following a thwarted terrorist plot in 2006. These measures added time and complexity to the security process.

Additionally, the introduction of trusted traveller programs like PreCheck and Global Entry aimed to expedite security for enrolled members but came at the cost of privacy, as participants surrendered personal information and submitted to extensive background checks.

As security measures evolved, airports also underwent redesigns to accommodate travellers spending more time in the terminals. The growth in air travel, combined with stringent security protocols, led to longer wait times and contributed to the development of airport malls, restaurants, and entertainment options.

While the enhanced security measures have been effective in preventing another large-scale attack, they have also made air travel more stressful and time-consuming for passengers, who now need to arrive at the airport hours in advance to ensure they make their flights.

The use of advanced imaging technology

The Transportation Security Administration (TSA) uses advanced imaging technology with automated target recognition software. This software eliminates passenger-specific images and instead auto-detects potential threats by indicating their location on a generic outline of a person. This technology ensures that security screenings are conducted efficiently and effectively, enhancing the overall security of airports.

The implementation of advanced imaging technology is a notable example of how airport security has evolved since 9/11 to address emerging threats and improve the safety of passengers. By utilizing this technology, TSA officers are better equipped to identify potential dangers and prevent them from accessing aircrafts, ultimately contributing to a more secure aviation environment.

The deployment of advanced imaging technology demonstrates the ongoing efforts of security agencies to enhance their capabilities and stay one step ahead of potential threats. This technology not only improves security but also helps streamline the screening process, making it more convenient for travellers while ensuring their protection.

As technology continues to advance, it is expected that airport security will further evolve, incorporating new innovations to address the ever-changing landscape of security challenges. The use of advanced imaging technology exemplifies the commitment to ensuring the safety of passengers and adapting to meet the demands of modern air travel.

Frequently asked questions