Alternative Airports: Where Could Sullenberger Have Landed?

Chesley Burnett Sully Sullenberger III, a retired American aviator, gained fame for his heroic actions as captain of US Airways Flight 1549 on January 15, 2009. Shortly after takeoff, the plane encountered a critical situation, losing power in both engines due to a bird strike. Faced with limited options, Sullenberger skillfully executed an emergency landing on the Hudson River, earning the event the moniker 'Miracle on the Hudson'. This incident raises the question: what other airports could Sullenberger have landed at?

LaGuardia Airport

Sullenberger quickly determined that he would be unable to reach either LaGuardia or Teterboro Airport and made the decision to glide the plane towards the Hudson River for an emergency water landing. All 155 people on board were rescued by nearby boats, with no fatalities, although 100 people were injured, five of them seriously.

In the aftermath of the incident, there was some speculation as to whether the aircraft could have returned to LaGuardia. Flight simulations conducted by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) suggested that the aircraft could have returned safely to LaGuardia if it had turned towards the airport immediately after the bird strike. However, these simulations were considered unrealistic, as they did not account for the time required for the pilots to assess the situation and make a decision.

Sullenberger maintained that there was no time to attempt a return to LaGuardia and that doing so would have likely resulted in casualties onboard and on the ground. The Board ultimately ruled that Sullenberger had made the correct decision, as the normal procedures for engine loss are designed for cruising altitudes, not immediately after takeoff.

Teterboro Airport

In 2019, Teterboro Airport was the second busiest general aviation airport in the region, seeing 173,625 aircraft operations that year. During the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the airport saw a significant drop in total aircraft operations, with a reduction in traffic to 86,465 flights. However, Teterboro leads Republic Airport in transient flights, while Republic has more local general aviation traffic.

There have been several notable incidents at Teterboro Airport. In June 1966, a two-engine Piper Aztec going to the airport crashed, striking a tree and narrowly missing homes on Burton Avenue. On September 23, 1981, a helicopter and an airplane collided in flight about 2.3 miles south of the airport. The helicopter fell into the Meadowlands Sports Complex parking lot, and both persons aboard were killed. The airplane made an emergency landing in a marsh, with significant damage to its left wing and right engine.

Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger considered landing at Teterboro Airport after his US Airways Flight 1549 struck a flock of birds and lost power in both engines shortly after takeoff from LaGuardia Airport on January 15, 2009. However, Sullenberger quickly determined that he would be unable to reach either LaGuardia or Teterboro Airports and made the decision to glide the plane to an emergency water landing on the Hudson River near Midtown Manhattan. All 155 people on board were rescued, and there were no fatalities.

San Francisco International Airport

SFO is known for its unique terrain, and the FAA has classified it as a "special airport" due to its mountainous terrain and other challenges. One such challenge is the nearby Bay, which can make landing and taking off more difficult, especially in low-visibility conditions.

In 2013, a deadly plane crash occurred at SFO, and Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger, a retired aviator, diplomat, and aviation safety expert, noted that the FAA-mandated construction and a switched-off landing assistance system would likely be factors in the investigation. Sullenberger also highlighted that a nearby United Airlines crew may have had a "front-row seat" to the crash and could provide valuable information to investigators.

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) sent a team to investigate the cause of the crash, and aviation experts weighed in on possible factors, including power shortages and pilot error. SFO's unique characteristics and the circumstances of the crash highlight the importance of continuous learning and dedication to ensuring the best practices in aviation safety.

Heathrow Airport

In terms of safety, Heathrow Airport adheres to stringent protocols and is well-equipped to handle various scenarios. One crucial aspect of its safety infrastructure is the "Glide Path" landing assistance system. This system aids pilots in navigating and landing their aircraft safely. However, it is worth noting that during favourable weather conditions, the "Glide Path" system may be temporarily deactivated, as has occurred during certain summer months in the past.

Overall, Heathrow Airport is a prominent aviation hub that prioritises safety and passenger well-being. Its status as a "special airport" underscores the unique considerations that go into ensuring safe operations, and its proactive approach to safety enhancements further reinforces its dedication to protecting travellers and staff.

Charlotte Douglas International Airport

On January 15, 2009, Captain Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger III was at the helm of US Airways Flight 1549, an Airbus A320, which took off from LaGuardia Airport in New York City, destined for Charlotte Douglas International Airport in North Carolina. Shortly after takeoff, the plane collided with a flock of Canada geese, resulting in the loss of power in both engines.

Sullenberger, a seasoned aviator with over 30 years of commercial piloting experience, quickly assessed the situation and determined that returning to LaGuardia Airport or diverting to Teterboro Airport was not feasible. Instead, he made the bold decision to glide the aircraft towards the Hudson River for an emergency water landing, a manoeuvre that would later be dubbed the "Miracle on the Hudson".

While the airport boasts an impressive infrastructure, with multiple runways and state-of-the-art facilities, it is important to note that Sullenberger's decision to land on the Hudson River was influenced by the proximity and feasibility of reaching alternative airports. The loss of power in both engines presented a unique challenge, and Sullenberger's quick thinking and expertise led him to choose the Hudson River as the safest option for an emergency landing.

In conclusion, while Charlotte Douglas International Airport was the intended destination of Flight 1549, the unexpected bird strike and subsequent loss of engine power prompted Sullenberger to make a swift and calculated decision to opt for an emergency water landing on the Hudson River, ensuring the safety of all 155 passengers and crew members on board.

Frequently asked questions