Airport Temperature Checks: Effective Or Security Theater?

Temperature is a measure of the average kinetic energy of particles in an object. It is measured using a thermometer, which works by exposing the instrument to the atmosphere, allowing the surrounding air's temperature to permeate it and eventually balancing the thermometer's temperature with its own.

The placement of thermometers is important when it comes to getting accurate temperature readings. For instance, the official thermometer for the city of Phoenix is located at the airport, where it is placed 5 feet over unimproved ground. While this is done to ensure accurate observations for airplanes coming in and taking off, it is not necessarily the best location for measuring the city's temperature.

In fact, there are often significant variations in temperatures within the same city, and temperature scanners used to detect fevers in people (a symptom of COVID-19) may not always be reliable. For example, menopausal women going through hot flushes could be mistaken for having a fever when their skin temperature spikes, even though their body temperature remains normal.

Therefore, while temperature is measured at airports, the readings may not always be an accurate representation of the surrounding area.

Airports use thermoelectric thermometers to measure temperature

Airports are equipped with a range of instruments to monitor various weather conditions, including temperature, air pressure, wind speed and direction, wind shear, and lightning detection. Temperature measurements are crucial for aviation safety, as they impact aircraft performance and flight operations.

Thermoelectric thermometers, also known as thermocouples, are widely used at airports to measure temperature accurately. These devices consist of two wires made of different metals joined at each end, forming a circuit. One junction, placed in the area where temperature measurement is required, and the other is maintained at a constant lower temperature. This temperature difference generates an electromotive force, known as the Seebeck effect, which is proportional to the temperature discrepancy between the two junctions.

The standard height for placing official thermometers at airports is around five feet above the ground, aiming to measure air temperature close to human breathing level. Airports strive to maintain consistency in thermometer placement to ensure accurate and comparable data over time.

Thermoelectric thermometers offer advantages such as direct temperature reading, a wide temperature range, and low cost, making them a preferred choice for temperature measurement at airports.

Temperature sensors are placed in the shade to avoid direct sunlight

When placing temperature sensors, it is important to consider the surrounding environment. Sensors should be placed away from surfaces that can absorb sunlight and heat up, such as walls or pavement. In addition, sensors should be positioned at a height where people normally breathe. For example, official thermometers are typically placed at a height of 5 feet over unimproved ground.

The placement of temperature sensors can vary depending on the specific application. For aviation purposes, sensors are placed near runways to provide accurate information for pilots. In other cases, sensors may be placed outdoors in shaded areas or enclosed in radiation shields to protect them from direct sunlight while allowing airflow.

To ensure accurate temperature measurements, it is crucial to consider factors such as sunlight, airflow, and surrounding surfaces. By placing temperature sensors in the shade and following other best practices, more accurate and reliable data can be obtained.

Airports use temperature data for aviation safety

The placement of temperature sensors at airports is crucial for accurate measurements. Sensors are typically placed near runways for aviation safety and are positioned at a height of around 5 feet over unimproved ground. The National Weather Service (NWS) strives for consistency in temperature measurements across its network of stations. Automated instruments transmit temperature data to corresponding NWS offices, with backup instruments located elsewhere on airport grounds for added reliability.

While temperature measurements at airports are essential for aviation safety, there are concerns about their use for climate data. Some argue that airport temperature sensors are not ideally placed for climate tracking due to potential urban heat island effects and the influence of aircraft operations. The proximity of temperature sensors to asphalt, buildings, and other heat-generating sources can impact temperature readings.

To address these concerns, it is important to distinguish between temperature measurements for aviation safety and those for climate monitoring. Airports primarily use temperature data to ensure safe aircraft operations, and the placement of sensors reflects this purpose. Climate monitoring may benefit from different siting standards to minimize potential biases.

Temperature readings can be inaccurate due to faulty equipment

Inaccurate temperature readings can have significant impacts, especially in the context of airports. Temperature readings are crucial for aviation safety, as they affect the density of the air and, consequently, the performance of aircraft. Inaccurate readings can lead to unsafe conditions for takeoff and landing, potentially endangering lives.

Additionally, faulty equipment can result in incorrect temperature data being used for climate records. For instance, at Honolulu International Airport, a faulty temperature sensor recorded temperatures that were two degrees warmer than the actual temperature. This error was only discovered because it broke the record for the highest temperature in June, prompting further investigation. Similar instances of faulty equipment have been reported at other airports worldwide, raising concerns about the accuracy of climate data.

To address these issues, it is essential to have proper maintenance and calibration procedures in place for temperature-reading equipment. Regular checks and calibrations can help identify and rectify faulty sensors before they impact safety or data accuracy. Additionally, having backup instruments can provide redundancy and help identify discrepancies. By implementing robust procedures and utilizing advanced equipment, the accuracy and reliability of temperature readings can be significantly improved.

Temperature scanners are used to detect COVID-19 symptoms

Temperature scanners are used at airports and other busy locations to detect COVID-19 symptoms. Since fever is one of the primary symptoms of COVID-19, the idea is that scanning everyone's temperature will identify infected people before they can enter the building and possibly infect others.

Thermal scanners have been installed at entrances to reduce physical contact at a time of social distancing and to speed up the flow of employees during shift changes when entrances are most crowded. These scanners can also be used to look for hidden objects.

Thermal imaging systems can accurately detect a high body temperature when used properly. The system software locates and captures a person's precise body temperature using an accompanying display, monitored by staff to determine the severity of the patient's illness. When a person's body temperature rises above a certain threshold, the system emits an alarm.

However, temperature scanners are not perfect. They measure skin temperature, not core body temperature, so outside temperatures can affect the readings. For example, in hot weather, the scanner may detect a fever when a person doesn't have one, and in cold weather, it might not detect a fever when a person has one. Furthermore, many people with COVID-19 never develop a fever.

Therefore, while temperature scanners are a helpful tool, they are just one part of a multi-faceted approach to COVID-19 detection, which also includes symptom checks and contact tracing.

Frequently asked questions