Terrorist Questioning: Airport Security's Ethical Dilemma

In April 2022, a photo of a US airport kiosk with an unusual security question began circulating on social media. The image, shared by freelance journalist Asaad Sam Hanna and Twitter user Rajat Suresh, showed a self-check-in counter screen asking passengers, Are you a terrorist? with yes and no options. The post sparked a range of reactions, from amusement to confusion, and raised questions about the effectiveness of such questions in airport security. Some users wondered about the increased computerization of airport check-in processes and the potential for human error or deception. Others suggested that asking such questions could aid law enforcement in bringing additional charges if a terrorist lied. The incident highlighted the ongoing debate surrounding the balance between security and human interaction in airport settings.

The question Are you a terrorist? was likely a mistake, with the correct question being Are you a tourist?

In April 2022, a photo of a self-check-in kiosk at a US airport asking the question "Are you a terrorist?" went viral on Twitter. The image, shared by freelance journalist Asaad Sam Hanna, showed the "advanced level" of security at the airport, with the question "Are you a terrorist?" and two options: "yes" or "no".

While the image amused many social media users, some questioned how this form of questioning contributed to airport security. One person wrote: "I really don't understand how, since 9/11, our airport check-in has become more computerized, with much less human-to-human interactions. Given past observations by agents who have noticed suspicious behavior, this seems like a bad thing for security."

However, another user pointed out that asking this question could aid law enforcement: "If you are [a terrorist], and you lie, it's a way for law enforcement to bring additional charges."

It is likely that the question "Are you a terrorist?" was a mistake, and the correct question was meant to be "Are you a tourist?". This error, though humorous, highlights the importance of human interaction in airport security and the potential pitfalls of overly computerized systems. It also underscores the need for careful question design in security screenings to avoid confusion or unintended loopholes.

While the viral photo sparked debate about airport security measures, it also served as a reminder of the ongoing challenges faced by authorities in balancing effective security with efficient passenger processing. The incident demonstrates the complexities of airport security and the need for a multi-layered approach that utilizes both technology and human intelligence.

The question received a lot of attention on Twitter, with people joking about the question and wondering how it contributed to security

The question "Are you a terrorist?" appearing on a self-check-in kiosk at a US airport sparked a lot of attention and humour on Twitter, with people questioning its effectiveness as a security measure.

A photo of the kiosk screen displaying the question was shared on Twitter by freelance journalist Asaad Sam Hanna, who captioned it as an example of "advanced level security". The tweet sparked a wave of amused responses, with many people joking about the question and expressing their curiosity about what would happen if someone selected "yes". Some users even admitted to having an urge to press "yes" just to see the outcome.

The viral tweet garnered a significant number of likes and retweets, with people creating memes and sharing their imagined follow-up questions. One user jokingly commented that the question was their "favourite thing about airports", implying that terrorists would be expected to honestly disclose their intentions.

However, some Twitter users raised valid concerns about the increasing computerisation of airport security checks and the reduction in human interaction, especially given that suspicious behaviour has been noticed by agents in the past. They questioned how the simple yes-or-no question could effectively contribute to security when anyone could easily lie to the machine.

In contrast, a few people defended the question, suggesting that it could help law enforcement bring additional charges if a terrorist lied about their intentions.

Some people expressed concern about the increased computerization of airport check-in, arguing that human interaction is important for noticing suspicious behavior

In recent years, airport security has become increasingly computerized. AI-powered self-check-in kiosks and cameras have been introduced at airports across the United States, capturing the biometric data of passengers and using facial recognition technology. While some find this amusing, others have expressed concern about the reduction in human-to-human interactions during airport check-in.

A viral tweet by freelance journalist Asaad Sam Hanna in April 2022 highlighted a snapshot of a self-check-in counter at a US airport, where the in-built system asked passengers, "Are you a terrorist?" with "yes" or "no" options. This sparked a wave of responses from Twitter users, with some questioning the effectiveness of such a direct question in enhancing airport security. One user, Kerry Troup, pointed out that computerized check-ins could hinder the detection of suspicious behavior, which has been crucial in the past.

The increased computerization of airport check-in has sparked concerns among some people who argue that human interaction is vital for noticing suspicious behavior. They worry that security personnel may become overly reliant on technology, dulling their senses and ability to detect subtle signs of suspicious activity. This view is supported by aviation-security expert Arnold Barnett, who believes that certain indicators, such as profuse sweating, might be missed by a computer conducting an iris scan but could be noticed by a vigilant human screener.

However, proponents of automation in airport security claim that it could free human screeners to focus more intently on detecting suspicious behavior and monitoring flagged travelers. They argue that computers can be more thorough and less prone to errors than humans. While the debate continues, it is evident that a balance between technology and human interaction is crucial for ensuring effective airport security.

Others argued that asking the question could help law enforcement bring additional charges if a terrorist lied

A photo of a self-check-in kiosk at a US airport that asked the question "Are you a terrorist?" went viral on Twitter in April 2022. The post, shared by freelance journalist Asaad Sam Hanna, prompted a wave of responses from amused social media users who questioned the effectiveness of such a question in enhancing airport security.

However, some users argued that asking the question could be beneficial to law enforcement. Twitter user Lisa Borel explained that if a terrorist lied about being one, it could result in additional charges:

> If you are [a terrorist], and you lie, it's a way for law enforcement to bring additional charges. Then they will go for what they can make stick. Accused criminals have rights in the [US] court system, so prosecutors have to prove their case. If you lie, [it] establishes mens rea, intent to deceive.

This line of reasoning assumes that a terrorist would be more likely to lie about their intentions if asked directly and that a false response could provide additional evidence of criminal intent.

It is worth noting that the authenticity of the viral image could not be confirmed, and it may have been the result of an error, with one source suggesting that the question was likely meant to be "Are you a tourist?" Nonetheless, the incident sparked a broader discussion about airport security measures and the role of technology in identifying potential threats.

The US has deployed AI-powered self-check-in kiosks and cameras at airports, which use facial recognition technology and capture biometric data

The US has deployed AI-powered self-check-in kiosks and cameras at airports across the country. These machines use facial recognition technology and capture the biometric data of passengers flying into the country.

The kiosks are designed to streamline the check-in process, enhance security, and reduce operating costs. Passengers can identify themselves by scanning their passports, faces, or entering their flight numbers. The machine will then print their boarding pass and baggage tags. Passengers can then use the kiosk's barcode scanner to tag their luggage, which will be automatically scanned and sent to the baggage handling area.

The use of biometrics and facial recognition technology provides a high degree of accuracy in verifying the identity of individuals, making it difficult to forge or manipulate. This technology also allows passengers to pass through various checkpoints, such as security and boarding gates, without the need for physical documents. This interconnected system improves efficiency and streamlines airport operations.

Additionally, the contactless nature of the biometric border control system prevents possible contamination, making it a hygienic option, especially in the post-COVID era. Overall, the implementation of AI-powered self-check-in kiosks aims to improve the airport experience for passengers while also enhancing security measures.

Frequently asked questions