Quarantine At Airports: Is It A Reality For Travelers?

Quarantine measures have been implemented at airports worldwide in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Airports such as Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, and Incheon International Airport have implemented measures including health screenings, mandatory quarantines, and contact tracing for arriving passengers. These measures aim to reduce the spread of COVID-19 by identifying and isolating potentially infected individuals. However, the effectiveness of airport screening has been questioned, as asymptomatic and presymptomatic individuals can still transmit the virus. While these measures may disrupt travel plans and cause inconveniences, they are necessary to protect public health and reduce the impact of the pandemic.

Quarantined passengers stamped on their forearms at Delhi and Uttar Pradesh airports

In March 2020, Delhi and Uttar Pradesh airports in India began stamping "Home Quarantined" on the forearms of people who had been advised to self-quarantine after arriving from abroad. The measure was introduced to control the spread of COVID-19 and ensure travellers completed the necessary quarantine period. Passengers arriving at the Indira Gandhi International Airport in Delhi from abroad underwent two medical checks. The first was carried out by airport authorities, who performed an initial thermal screening and isolated symptomatic passengers. Those displaying symptoms were moved to designated hospitals, while others proceeded to a second screening point run by the Delhi government, where they were either home quarantined or sent to a government-run quarantine facility depending on risk factors. The stamp also included the date of when the person was stamped, and the message: "Proud to protect Delhiites. Home quarantined".

The decision to start stamping came after authorities found people who had been advised to self-quarantine mingling in public spaces. The ink used was indelible, similar to the kind used to mark voters, and was applied at the second screening point.

In the state of Uttar Pradesh, the message stamped in Hindi translated to: "Proud to help my countrymen stay free from Coronavirus. Home quarantined".

The introduction of the stamps caused some controversy, with complaints that the ink could be easily smudged and transferred. Congress leader Madhu Goud Yakshi shared a picture on social media of the ink smudged on his hand, prompting the Delhi Airport to respond:

> "We deeply regret the inconvenience caused. The ink used for stamping is a standard indelible ink. We've reported the issue to the Delhi State authorities. Currently, this batch of ink is being kept aside for testing by the supplier and further desired action. Thank you for highlighting the issue."

The Indian Health Ministry also instructed airlines not to carry passengers with "home quarantined" stamps on domestic flights.

The screening process at airports

Pre-Arrival Screening

Before arriving at the airport, passengers are often encouraged to refer to health guidelines and travel restrictions to ensure they are fit to fly and comply with the necessary requirements. Some countries may also have specific pre-travel procedures, such as pre-departure testing and health declarations.

Check-In and Documentation Screening

Upon arrival at the airport, passengers must present their boarding passes and may be required to show photo identification. This initial screening step ensures that passengers have the necessary travel documents and helps verify their identity.

Security Screening

The security screening process typically involves passing through metal detectors or advanced imaging technology, such as full-body scanners, to detect any prohibited items, including weapons and explosives. Passengers are also screened for certain behaviours and may be subjected to additional screening if they trigger alarms or are randomly selected.

During security screening, passengers are required to place their carry-on items, such as electronics, food, and liquids, in designated bins to undergo X-ray screening. This process helps identify any prohibited items or substances that may pose a security or safety risk.

Health Screening

In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, health screening measures have become an integral part of the airport screening process. Passengers may undergo temperature checks and be assessed for visible symptoms. Those exhibiting symptoms or failing the temperature screening may be escorted to a dedicated health station for further evaluation and isolation.

Additional Screening Measures

Depending on the situation, additional screening measures may be implemented. For example, during the COVID-19 pandemic, some countries implemented quarantine requirements for arriving passengers. This involved stamping travellers advised to undergo home quarantine or directing them to government-run quarantine facilities.

Final Screening and Boarding

After completing the necessary screening processes, passengers retrieve their carry-on baggage and proceed towards their departure gates. At this stage, there may be additional document checks or security screenings before passengers are allowed to board their flights.

It is important to note that the screening process may vary slightly across different airports and countries, and passengers are advised to stay informed about the specific requirements of their departure and arrival airports.

The low yield of airport screening

During the COVID-19 pandemic, airport screening was implemented in many countries to help prevent the spread of the virus. However, the effectiveness of these screenings has been questioned, with some suggesting that they were costly and had a low yield in detecting cases.

From January 17, 2020, to September 13, 2020, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), in collaboration with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), conducted a study to evaluate the effectiveness of airport screening programs in the United States. During this period, a total of 766,044 travelers were screened, with only nine individuals testing positive for COVID-19, resulting in a yield of about one positive case per 85,000 screened individuals. This low yield suggests that airport screening may not be the most effective method for detecting COVID-19 cases.

The screening process consisted of three steps. First, travelers who had been in specified high-risk locations within the previous 14 days were identified and referred for screening. This included places like Wuhan, China, mainland China, Iran, several countries in Europe, the United Kingdom, Ireland, and Brazil. Next, an initial screening was conducted, which included a temperature check and a questionnaire about symptoms and potential exposure. Finally, those considered high-risk underwent further assessment, including testing for COVID-19.

The low yield of the airport screening program could be attributed to several factors. One reason could be the overall low prevalence of COVID-19 in travelers during the study period. Additionally, the relatively long incubation period of the virus, the wide range of symptom severity, the presence of afebrile cases, and nonspecific symptoms that overlap with other infections may have contributed to the low yield. Furthermore, asymptomatic infections and travelers who may deny symptoms or take medication to suppress fever or cough could also have impacted the effectiveness of the screening.

While airport screening may not be sufficient on its own to prevent the spread of COVID-19, it is important to note that it is just one layer of a multi-layered approach to controlling the pandemic. Other measures, such as social distancing, face mask use, hand hygiene, and active disinfection of surfaces in airports and on airplanes, are crucial components of a comprehensive strategy.

To improve the effectiveness of travel-related COVID-19 prevention measures, the CDC has shifted its focus to enhancing communication with travelers, promoting recommended preventive measures, strengthening response capacity at ports of entry, and encouraging pre-departure and post-arrival testing. Additionally, collecting contact information from international air passengers before their arrival and facilitating real-time data transfer to health departments can facilitate timely post-arrival management and contact tracing when needed.

The impact of airport screening on travellers

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on global travel, with airport screening measures being implemented to curb the spread of the virus. These measures have had both positive and negative effects on travellers, and this article will explore these impacts in detail.

Disruptions and Delays

One of the most noticeable impacts of airport screening is the increased time required for travellers to navigate through airports. With health checks, temperature screenings, and additional paperwork, travellers often experience delays and disruptions to their journeys. These delays can be significant, as seen in the case of Brian Kim, who spent approximately four hours from landing to reaching his hotel room due to the various screening procedures at Incheon Airport in Seoul.

Quarantine Requirements

In some cases, travellers who are identified as potentially infected or at high risk of infection are required to undergo mandatory quarantine periods. This can range from self-quarantine at a designated location, such as an Airbnb or hotel, to quarantine at a government-run facility. For example, during the early stages of the pandemic, travellers arriving at Delhi Airport in India were stamped "Home Quarantined" on their forearms and required to undergo a 14-day quarantine.

Mental Health Impact

The uncertainty and stress associated with airport screening and potential quarantine can take a toll on the mental health of travellers. The fear of failing a temperature check or being identified as a close contact of a positive case can cause anxiety and worry. Additionally, the isolation and restrictions imposed during quarantine periods can lead to feelings of loneliness and depression.

Financial Implications

Airport screening measures and quarantine requirements can also have financial implications for travellers. In some cases, travellers may need to bear the cost of extended stays at hotels or alternative accommodations. For example, at the Best Western Premier near Incheon Airport, travellers were required to pay approximately $1,760 per person for their quarantine stay, which included meals and coronavirus testing.

Impact on Travel Plans

The risk of being identified as a potential case or close contact during airport screening has led to a decrease in travel plans, especially for those travelling for leisure. Many individuals opt to avoid non-essential travel to reduce the chances of being subjected to quarantine requirements or possible infection during their journey. This has had a significant impact on the travel industry, with flight schedules being slashed and a decrease in traveller numbers.

While airport screening measures are essential to curb the spread of COVID-19, they have had a notable impact on travellers. From disruptions and delays to financial implications and mental health concerns, travellers have had to navigate a new set of challenges when embarking on their journeys. As the pandemic continues to evolve, it is crucial for travellers to stay informed about the latest requirements and restrictions to ensure a smooth and safe journey.

The effectiveness of airport screening

The COVID-19 pandemic has led to the implementation of various public health measures at Points of Entry (POEs) such as airports, seaports, and land crossings to detect, delay, or prevent the transmission of the virus. These measures include health screening, which involves procedures such as temperature checks, health declarations, visual inspections, exposure assessments, and testing. This discussion will focus on the effectiveness of airport screening in identifying infected individuals and preventing the spread of COVID-19.

Effectiveness of Airport Screening in Detecting COVID-19 Cases

Airport screening has been shown to have varying levels of effectiveness in detecting COVID-19 cases. Some studies indicate that airport screening measures can detect a significant number of cases, including variants of concern. Modeling studies predict that POE screening can detect COVID-19 cases in a range of 8.8% to 99.6%. Observational studies indicate a detection rate of 2% to 77.9%, depending on the screening methods employed.

However, it is important to note that the detection rate may vary depending on the sensitivity and specificity of screening devices, evolving border health policies, and changing disease transmission dynamics. Additionally, the effectiveness of airport screening can be influenced by factors such as the cooperation of passengers, masking of symptoms, inadequate human resources, and insufficient screening infrastructure.

Effectiveness of Airport Screening in Delaying and Reducing COVID-19 Transmission

Airport screening has also been found to be effective in delaying the onset of COVID-19 outbreaks and reducing the risk of transmission. Modeling studies suggest that airport screening measures can delay the onset of the epidemic by 7 to 32 days. Additionally, these measures can reduce the risk of disease transmission during travel by 30-35% through symptom screening and immediate isolation. Implementing testing for all asymptomatic travelers during exit screening can further reduce the risk of exportation by 44-72%.

Comparison with Other Public Health Interventions

When compared with other public health interventions, airport screening has been found to be more effective in preventing the importation of COVID-19 cases. However, it is important to note that the overall effectiveness of airport screening may depend on the combination of screening strategies employed and the specific context of the country or region.

Guidelines and Recommendations

International organizations such as the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) have published guidelines and recommendations for airport screening. These guidelines emphasize the importance of a risk-based approach over universal testing for all travelers. Additionally, they recommend against requiring proof of COVID-19 vaccination as a condition for entry or exit from a country due to vaccine distribution inequalities.

Airport screening has been shown to be effective in detecting COVID-19 cases and delaying the onset of outbreaks. However, the effectiveness of airport screening can vary depending on various factors, and it should be combined with other public health interventions for maximum benefit. The benefits of airport screening need to be weighed against the resources and costs involved, especially in countries with limited resources and high rates of infectious diseases such as HIV and tuberculosis.

Frequently asked questions