Heated Runways: Costly Innovation Or Winter Travel Savior?

Thousands of flights are delayed or cancelled each year due to winter weather. Snow and ice on runways can cause planes to skid off, leading to flight interruptions. Heated runways have been proposed as a solution to this problem. This technology involves embedding stainless steel electrodes within the concrete, which are then connected to a power source to generate heat and melt ice and snow. While heated runways can help cut down on flight delays and cancellations, there are concerns about their economic viability and environmental impact. The installation cost for this technology is estimated to be around $200 million for an average-size airport, but it is expected to save up to $273 million for airlines, airports, and passengers over time.

Cost of installation

The cost of installing heated runways depends on the technology used. For example, installing heated runways using geothermal systems can cost around $20 per square foot, excluding the cost of the well and pumping system. On the other hand, heat pipe systems, which use normal ground temperatures, are estimated to cost around $35 per square foot.

The Iowa State University team that developed the technology for heated runways estimates that it would cost about $200 million to install the technology in the most congested areas of an average-size airport. This estimate is based on the assumption that the technology will be used in areas such as airport hard stands, refueling areas, baggage handling areas, and passenger walkways, where it is most beneficial from a safety and economic standpoint.

The high initial cost of installing heated runways can be offset by the long-term savings it can provide. The Iowa State University team estimates that their technology could save airlines, airports, and passengers up to $273 million over time. This is because heated runways can help reduce flight delays and cancellations due to winter weather conditions, as well as prevent accidents caused by snow and ice on runways, taxiways, and tarmacs.

Additionally, the versatility of the technology allows for custom designs and optimizations for specific transportation infrastructure applications, including sidewalks, driveways, bridges, roads, and highways. This versatility stems from the fact that the technology is typically implemented as a conductive concrete overlay on top of the existing structure, making it a more cost-effective solution.

Energy requirements

The energy requirements for heated runways are substantial, and the technology is still in the development stage. The Iowa State University team, led by Halil Ceylan, has created a system that uses stainless steel electrodes embedded in concrete and connected to a power source to generate heat, melting ice and snow. This technology was demonstrated at Des Moines International Airport, where it successfully melted snow within minutes.

The power requirements for such a system are significant. For a 7,000ft x 150ft runway, the estimated installation cost is $21 million, in addition to the cost of the runway itself. The power consumption is estimated at 333 watts per square meter. For a large airport like Heathrow, with approximately 756,000 square meters of runway, the total power draw would be around 252 megawatts. Operating this system for 10 hours during a snow event would consume 2,520-megawatt hours of electricity, resulting in a cost of around $252,000 at consumer rates.

However, airports, as bulk consumers of electricity, may be able to negotiate better rates, and the potential benefits of reduced delays and cancellations could outweigh the energy costs. The Iowa State University team estimates that their technology could save airlines, airports, and passengers up to $273 million over time.

Additionally, the choice of energy source is crucial. Ideally, a low-cost energy source like geothermal energy is preferred. Other suggestions include running condenser cooling water from a power plant nearby or using solar power to run heated wires or mats.

Environmental impact

Heated runways can have a significant environmental impact. Firstly, they can reduce the use of chemical de-icers, which have negative effects on the environment. These chemicals can cause corrosion to aircraft and have adverse effects on the local environment and local water sources. By using heated runways, airports can avoid releasing these harmful substances into the environment.

Additionally, heated runways can help to reduce operation costs and enhance passenger safety. They can prevent cancellations and diversions of flights due to icy conditions, ensuring smoother airport operations and reducing disruptions for travellers.

Another environmental benefit of heated runways is their ability to stabilise the surface temperature. This can lessen the wear and tear caused by expansion and contraction of the runway surface due to temperature changes. As a result, heated runways can increase the lifespan of runways, reducing the need for frequent surface replacements and minimising downtime for maintenance.

Furthermore, heated runways can be powered by environmentally friendly renewable energy sources, such as solar energy or geothermal energy. This can help airports reduce their carbon footprint and move towards more sustainable operations.

However, there is also a potential drawback regarding the accuracy of climate data. As a significant portion of global surface air temperature measurements are taken at airports, heated runways might bias the "climate signal" upwards during winter, impacting the global climate data. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider the placement of weather stations and ensure they are located at a safe distance from heated surfaces to maintain data accuracy.

Runway maintenance

Regular Inspections and Monitoring: Conduct routine inspections of the heated runway system, including the electrical connections, stainless steel electrodes, and concrete surface. This proactive approach will help identify any potential issues or damage and facilitate timely repairs.

Calibration and Testing: Calibrate and test the heating system periodically to ensure it is functioning optimally. This includes checking the heating levels, response time, and uniformity of heat distribution across the runway. Any discrepancies or underperforming areas should be addressed promptly.

Preventative Maintenance: Establish a comprehensive preventative maintenance program to minimize the risk of unexpected failures. This should include regular cleaning and maintenance of the runway surface, as well as inspections for cracks, potholes, or other signs of wear and tear.

Collaborative Efforts: Coordinate with airport authorities, airlines, and other stakeholders to develop a comprehensive runway maintenance plan. This collaborative approach will help ensure that maintenance activities do not disrupt flight operations and that all parties are aware of any necessary adjustments or closures.

Data-Driven Decision-Making: Leverage data analytics and performance metrics to optimize maintenance strategies. By analyzing historical data and trends, maintenance teams can identify areas of the runway that may require more frequent attention or adjustments to heating levels.

Safety Considerations: Prioritize the safety of maintenance personnel and airport staff at all times. Establish standard operating procedures and safety protocols for working on and around heated runways, including procedures for handling electrical components and ensuring the runway is safe for aircraft operations following maintenance activities.

By implementing these maintenance practices, airports can maximize the benefits of heated runways, minimize disruptions, and enhance the overall efficiency of flight operations during winter weather conditions.

Impact on weather monitoring

Heated runways may have a significant impact on weather monitoring. A large portion of the world's surface air temperature data is collected at airports, with weather stations placed near the runways. If heated runways become commonplace, the data from these weather stations will likely show a bias towards higher temperatures in winter due to the waste heat from the heated runways. This could, in turn, influence global climate data.

To address this potential issue, it has been suggested that temperature monitoring stations be set up at varying distances from the heated runway surfaces to determine a safe distance for weather stations to provide accurate climate data. Additionally, it has been proposed that official climate monitoring locations be relocated further away from heated surfaces.

Furthermore, it is important to consider the impact of other airport operations, such as jet engines, on temperature measurements. Airports with higher traffic volumes and more frequent take-offs and landings may experience higher temperatures due to the heat generated by aircraft engines. Therefore, the placement of weather stations and the interpretation of temperature data from airports need to be carefully considered to minimise any potential biases in climate data.

Frequently asked questions